Rising from the Ashes: How to Start a Phoenix Company the Right Way
Starting Over with a Phoenix Company: What’s Legal, What’s Not
When a company becomes insolvent, restarting can feel out of reach. But for directors with a viable business model, committed team, and loyal clients, a new beginning may be possible; if it’s done the right way. This is where phoenix companies come in.
A phoenix company is a new legal entity formed after the closure of a previous business. It often continues the same or similar operations by purchasing key assets such as equipment, intellectual property, or contracts from the original company. In many cases, the directors, staff, or suppliers remain unchanged. While this setup is lawful, it comes with strict rules. Directors must ensure transparency, pay fair price for assets, and avoid misleading creditors or the public. When handled properly, phoenixing can be a legitimate recovery route.
This article explains how the phoenix process works, what makes it legal, and the common risks to avoid. It covers name restrictions under Section 216 of the Insolvency Act, asset transfer rules, and the importance of using licensed insolvency professionals at each stage.
What Is a Phoenix Company?
A phoenix company describes a new business formed after the insolvency of a previous one. Its purpose is to continue viable operations; such as delivering services, preserving client relationships, or retaining staff while leaving behind unmanageable liabilities. This process is only lawful when carried out through formal insolvency procedures and in line with specific legal safeguards.
Typically, a phoenix company emerges through liquidation or administration, overseen by a licensed insolvency practitioner. The transfer of assets from the old business to the new entity must be properly valued and documented to protect creditor interests. These steps are governed by UK insolvency law, which is designed to ensure fairness and transparency.
While restarting in this way can be perfectly legal, the approach is heavily regulated due to past abuses. Directors who do not follow the rules risk personal liability, disqualification, and reputational damage. UK regulators continue to monitor phoenix behaviour closely, particularly where there is any suggestion of misconduct or intent to avoid debts.
Under the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986, directors involved in misconduct during insolvency may be banned from running other businesses for a set period. This makes it essential to record all key decisions clearly and seek professional advice early in the process.
How a phoenix company is structured reflects directly on the directors involved. A compliant and well-documented restart can preserve value and protect jobs. But if there’s any suggestion of undervalued asset transfers or improper staff handling, both creditors and regulators may question the legitimacy of the new business. The goal is not just to meet legal minimums, it’s to rebuild with integrity from the start.
Key Legal Risks and Watchpoints
1. Using the Same or Similar Name (Section 216, Insolvency Act 1986)
If you were a director of a company in the 12 months before its liquidation, you cannot form or manage another company with the same name, or a name that is similar, for five years. This restriction is automatic and applies even if the original name is slightly changed.
There are only three legal exceptions:
Court Permission: You can apply to the court within seven days of the liquidation. If granted, this allows you to use the restricted name.
Business Sale Exception: If you purchase the business from the liquidator, and notify all creditors and advertise the details in the London Gazette, you may continue using the name.
12-Month Rule for Existing Companies: If the new company has traded continuously under the same name for at least 12 months before the liquidation of the previous company, the restriction does not apply. However, the trading must be genuine and verifiable.
Breaching Section 216 can result in criminal prosecution. It can also make you personally liable for all debts of the new company. Regulators assess how the new business appears from the outside. If the name, branding, or operations seem too close to the former company, they may take action even without formal links.
2. Shadow Directorship
Even without an official title, a person making decisions or influencing management can be classed as a shadow director. Shadow directors face the same legal responsibilities and risks as appointed directors.
Regulators monitor the behaviour of individuals behind the scenes, especially when misconduct is suspected. This scrutiny applies to anyone directing business decisions informally or acting through proxies. Restarting without formal roles does not reduce risk. Instead, it increases exposure to disqualification or claims of concealment. Clear governance and open communication are essential safeguards.
3. Asset Transfers and Tax Avoidance Red Flags
Transferring company assets before formal insolvency, especially when tax debts remain unpaid, is a common red flag. HMRC now has broader powers to investigate these actions, with a specific focus on undervalued asset sales that appear designed to avoid liabilities.
Such conduct may be treated as fraudulent under UK insolvency law. If found responsible, directors may face personal liability for tax debts or other losses, even after the phoenix company is set up. Building a clean restart requires transparency throughout the process, including full valuations and documented asset transfers.
What Makes a Phoenix Legal and Credible
1. Brand and Identity Overhaul
It’s important to clearly distinguish the new business from the one that failed. A new company name, website, email domain, and branding can help prevent confusion among creditors, clients, and regulators. If the new business appears too similar to the previous one, particularly in cases where directors remain involved, it may raise concerns. Even where reuse is permitted under Section 216 rules, keeping the identity distinct helps demonstrate that the new company is not simply a continuation of the old one.
2. Transparent Governance
All director and shareholder roles must be clearly declared. If individuals from the previous company are involved, they may need legal clearance to continue. Transparency in leadership structures supports trust and reduces the risk of accusations of concealment or improper control.
3. TUPE Compliance for Employees
When a phoenix company takes on staff from the previous business, the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations (TUPE) may apply. These rules are designed to protect employee rights in business transfers, even after insolvency.
TUPE can mean that existing employment contracts move over to the new company automatically. This includes continuity of service, existing terms and conditions, and in some cases, union recognition. Employers must carry out proper employee consultations and consider the legal risks of redundancy or changes in role.
Getting this right is not just a compliance issue; it affects team morale, trust, and business continuity.
4. Fair Asset Transfer
Assets transferred from the old company to a phoenix company must be sold at fair market value. This applies to both physical and intangible assets, including stock, equipment, software, customer data, and intellectual property. Each transfer must be properly valued and documented.
A licensed insolvency practitioner is responsible for managing the process. Their role includes:
Commissioning professional valuations
Marketing assets openly where appropriate
Keeping detailed records to protect creditor interests
Asset transfers that do not reflect market value may trigger claims of undervalue transactions or fraudulent trading. If challenged, courts will examine how the transaction was handled, whether creditors were treated fairly, and whether the process followed proper procedures.
Where disputes arise, clear documentation and independent valuations are essential. These details often determine whether a transaction is treated as a lawful sale or escalated into a regulatory investigation.
Understanding Pre-Pack Sales in a Phoenix Restructure
One way to handle asset transfers efficiently is through a pre-pack sale. This is a structured insolvency process where a company’s assets are sold immediately after the appointment of an administrator. In many phoenix scenarios, this allows the new business to continue trading without major interruption.
To ensure legal and ethical compliance, a pre-pack sale must meet the following conditions:
Arranged by a licensed insolvency practitioner
Assets sold at fair market value, supported by an independent valuation
The sale must serve the best interests of creditors, not just directors or shareholders
If the buyer is a connected party (e.g. same directors), the sale must be reviewed by an independent evaluator within 48 hours
When structured correctly, pre-pack sales help preserve value, protect jobs, and maintain relationships with customers and suppliers. But they must be managed transparently, with clear documentation and oversight. Failure to do so may lead to claims of misconduct or regulatory intervention.
The Restaurant Analogy: A Cautionary Tale
Imagine a restaurant closes due to poor management and unpaid debts. A week later, a "new" restaurant opens in the same location, using the same staff, same menu, and nearly identical branding. The name is slightly different, but the rest looks unchanged. This isn’t a fresh start. It’s a continuation of the same business, minus the liabilities.
To regulators, that’s not a legitimate phoenix; it’s an attempt to avoid obligations. Now compare that to a new restaurant launched elsewhere, with new branding, proper asset transfer records, and compliance checks completed. That’s what a lawful phoenix company looks like.
Personal Liability: Real Enforcement Examples
Phoenix activity continues to face close regulatory scrutiny. Recent enforcement cases include:
Phoenix Tech Limited: Directors were found personally liable for £4.5 million in VAT fraud after forming a phoenix company and using false invoices. The tribunal ruled that they had direct knowledge of the misuse of the company structure.
Rodney and Pauline Wallace: Sentenced to 27 and 10 months respectively for diverting £111,000 to a phoenix company and attempting to access frozen funds under false pretences.
Thorne v Silverleaf: The High Court confirmed that even technical breaches of Section 216; such as reusing a name without meeting the correct exemption, can result in personal liability for all of the phoenix company’s debts.
These cases illustrate how even small missteps in governance, naming, or asset transfer can lead to serious consequences.
Phoenix Company Checklist
Before you rebuild, make sure you:
Create a brand-new company name (no similarity to the previous one)
Redesign your visual identity and website
Purchase old assets at fair value with documentation
Identify and document all governance roles
Complete a TUPE review and employee consultations
Migrate data legally and securely (GDPR-compliant)
Open new client contracts, insurance policies, and bank accounts
Notify clients and suppliers clearly
Avoid using any of the old company’s branding or materials without legal rights
Protect the interests of creditors, employees, and other stakeholders at every stage
If any of these steps are incomplete, it may not yet be safe or legal to restart.
Avoiding Phoenix Company Missteps
Even with the right intentions, how a restructure appears to others can carry risk. If your new business closely mirrors the failed company; through similar branding, digital assets, or customer messaging, it may raise concerns. Regulators, creditors, and customers could interpret this as an attempt to avoid liabilities, especially if key safeguards aren’t in place.
Accusations of phoenix company fraud can lead to formal investigations, personal liability, and reputational damage. A clear separation plan, transparent governance, and early legal advice are essential steps in reducing these risks. Directors must also be aware that, under UK law, non-compliant restructures may be successfully challenged by regulators or creditors.
Ready for a Compliant Restart?
A phoenix company can offer a lawful way to restart operations, but only when handled with care. Success depends on structure, transparency, and compliance; not shortcuts.
Before making decisions around asset transfers, staff retention, or branding, seek independent legal advice. This helps protect both the new business and the individuals involved.
Want help planning your next steps? Book a restructure audit. We’ll help you rebuild with clarity, compliance, and control, so your business is ready to move forward with confidence.
Frequently Asked Questions About Phoenix Companies
-
Yes, starting a new company after insolvency is legal in the UK; but only if you follow the correct legal procedures. This includes rules around company names (Section 216), asset transfers, and director conduct.
-
Yes, you can retain staff, but TUPE regulations may apply. This means employment rights usually carry over and must be handled correctly. If the new company continues the insolvent company’s business, employee transfer obligations must be considered from the outset.
-
If you reuse a restricted company name without a valid exemption, you could face:
Personal liability for the new company’s debts
Criminal prosecution
Director disqualification for up to 15 years
This rule exists to prevent confusion between the second company and the original, particularly when existing directors or similar branding are involved.
-
No. Individuals who are personally bankrupt cannot legally act as company directors or form a new limited company until they are discharged. Attempting to direct a business in such a scenario may trigger further restrictions under insolvency law.
-
The official receiver oversees the administration or liquidation process, investigates the reasons for failure, and works to protect creditor interests. The Insolvency Service may also step in to investigate misconduct and monitor phoenix activity.
-
Yes, as long as it complies with all legal requirements. The new business must manage cash flow carefully and demonstrate financial stability to avoid repeating past issues. Seeking advice from a qualified insolvency practitioner appointed during the restructure can help ensure continuity and alignment with legal expectations.
Similar Posts We Think You’ll Like
Learn what management accounts are, why most businesses need them, and what to include in every report. A practical guide for tracking business performance, financial planning, and making informed decisions.